Brian Hedden's Fairness Argument

Based off Brian Hedden’s People Coins and Rooms Through Experiment

Argument

P1: In People, Coins and Rooms Though Experiment algorithm assigns risk equal to coin bias and is perfectly fair
P2: Algorithm violates every proposed statistical fairness except for calibration within groups
C: None of those proposed criteria apart from calibration within groups are geniuine requirements for fairness

Counter Arguments

• Hedden Fairnes Argument No Stakes Objection
• Hedden Fairnes Argument Improbability Objection
• Heddens Fairness Argument Individualized Information Objection